Based on the provided Douban comments, here is a summary of the audience feedback for this TV series (adapted from *Rebirth of a Female General Star* and titled *Legend of The Female General*):
---
### **Main Criticisms (Concentrated Negative Feedback)**
1. **Heavy Plot Alterations, Deviating from the Original Core**
- Removal of the crucial "rebirth" element weakens the female lead's motivation for revenge (betrayal by family, murder by former husband), diminishing the story's tension and logic.
- Key plot points (e.g., the brother impersonating the protagonist) lack credibility. The fact that the entire court fails to distinguish between siblings with completely different builds and voices is criticized as "insulting to intelligence."
- Many iconic scenes from the original are cut, while newly added plots (e.g., embracing on the battlefield, coincidental hot spring encounters) are labeled as "industrial sugar" and "forced romance."
2. **Character Derailment, Female General Becomes "Trophy Wife"**
- The female lead, meant to be a resilient and decisive general, frequently displays "acting cute," "coquettishness," and "girlish mannerisms," criticized as "fake strong female lead, real trophy wife."
- The actress's petite and slender physique (mocked as "chick-sized") lacks the imposing presence expected of a "general." While there are many action scenes, they lack conviction.
- The male lead is altered to be more dominant, and the plot overemphasizes the romantic line, resulting in a "strong female lead, even stronger male lead" dynamic that undermines the female lead's independence.
3. **Acting and Dubbing Issues**
- Zhou Ye's acting is criticized as "wooden" and lacking in expressive eyes, especially in blind scenes where her performance shows no difference after regaining sight. However, some viewers praise her androgynous look in male attire.
- Cheng Lei's performance is considered flat, with dubbing that doesn't match his face. His character is perceived as an "expressionless ice block" with little depth.
- The overall dubbing is criticized as "lifeless" and "not fitting the characters."
4. **Logical Flaws and Sloppy Details**
- The plot is jumpy with abrupt transitions (e.g., blindness cured in 5 minutes, sudden embraces and kisses on the battlefield).
- Military aspects are trivialized (impractical masks, lax camp management), and the political intrigue subplot is weak.
- Dialogue is preachy and slogan-like (e.g., "women can also achieve great deeds"), coming across as forced.
5. **Casting Controversies**
- Zhou Ye is considered too "delicate" in appearance to portray a female general; the male lead is also described as having "rat-like features" and being "too effeminate."
- Supporting role casting (e.g., Yan He transformed into a middle-aged man) causes dissatisfaction, and some important characters are cut.
---
### **Points of Praise and Support (Minority Positive Feedback)**
1. **Actors' Visual Appeal and Styling**
- Zhou Ye's male attire is praised as "handsome" and "heroic," while her female looks are also called "stunning."
- Some viewers appreciate the high attractiveness of the leads and the visually pleasing scenes.
2. **Action Choreography and Production**
- The fight sequences are well-designed and fluid (action direction by the team from *Strange Tales of Tang Dynasty*), with some action scenes receiving recognition.
- Costumes, makeup, sets, and overall visual quality receive some positive remarks.
3. **Perceived Rationality of Adaptations**
- A minority of viewers believe removing the rebirth and inner-house conflict plots makes the story tighter, and focusing on "revenge in the present life" is more logical.
- Some appreciate plot points like the male lead quickly discovering the female lead's identity and the faster progression of the romance.
---
### **Divergence in Audience Groups**
- **Original Novel Fans Largely Disappointed**: They feel the adaptation loses the essence of the original, with severe alterations, mostly giving 1-2 star ratings.
- **TV-Only Viewers Are Divided**: Some find it "watchable as light entertainment," while others criticize the clichéd plot and logical flaws.
- **Actors' Fans Are Supportive**: They primarily praise the leads' looks and styling, being more tolerant of plot controversies.
---
### **Overall Summary**
The series is highly controversial. The core issue is that **"the alterations severely weaken the original's strong female lead core,"** leading to character derailment and logical flaws. While the production and action choreography have some merits, and the leads' visuals are praised, the plot adaptation, acting performances, and attention to detail face substantial criticism. Based on these Douban comments, **negative feedback dominates**, especially from original novel fans and viewers who prioritize plot logic. Overall, the reception reflects "high expectations, low satisfaction," with the series criticized as "yet another pseudo-strong-female-lead historical romance."
What do Chinese viewers think of the TV series The Immortal Ascension?
This TV drama adaptation of "A Record of a Mortal's Journey to Immortality," starring Yang Yang, has sparked widespread and polarized discussions, with focus primarily on the following aspects:
### **Praise and Highlights**
1. **Yang Yang's Appearance and Perceived Improvement:**
* **Positive Views:** Many viewers consider Yang Yang's **ancient costume appearance to be outstanding**, perfectly matching the handsome image of the protagonist, Han Li. Some comments noted that compared to his previous works, his performance in this drama showed some **improvement, being less "oily" and more natural**.
* **Praise for Production:** Many reviews praised the magnificent visuals from **on-location shooting** and the **film-level special effects**, considering the fight scenes exciting and the VFX plentiful and sincere, far exceeding the standard for typical domestic dramas.
* **Plot Fidelity and Pacing:** Some original novel and anime fans were satisfied with the **faithfulness to the source material**, finding the beginning well-paced and the main storyline clear, calling it an immersive "immortality cultivation" story. The female director's **skill in depicting nuanced emotions** (e.g., the portrayal of characters like Doctor Mo) was also praised.
### **Criticism and Controversy**
1. **Strong Criticism of Yang Yang's Acting:**
* This is the most contentious point. A significant number of viewers feel his performance remains **"oily," "affected," and "stiff,"** with a "news anchor-like" tone and unclear diction. They argue he failed to capture Han Li's essential traits of **caution, restraint, and intelligence**, instead coming across as "slow-witted" or "overconfident."
* Many critics compared his performance to his past roles, believing he has shown little improvement.
2. **Issues with Direction, Script, and Pacing:**
* Many comments point to **weak narrative skills from the director**, stating the plot feels like a "tedious流水账 (lit. running water account)" or a "scenic MV," with **poor pacing** (slow when it should be fast, and vice versa) and a lack of dramatic tension.
* **Inappropriate use of BGM** was cited, being described as overly abundant, chaotic, and mismatched with the scene's atmosphere.
* **Excessive use of voice-over narration** was criticized as a lazy way to explain characters' inner thoughts.
3. **Casting and Supporting Roles:**
* Beyond Yang Yang, **several actresses (e.g., Jin Chen, Liu Yan, Ying Er)** were criticized for being **miscast or incongruous** with their roles.
* The acting of some **supporting characters** was deemed exaggerated and one-dimensional.
4. **Flaws in Production Details:**
* While the VFX were praised overall, some early effects were called cheap and unimpressive.
* **Costumes, makeup, props, and set design** were considered rough by some, with the **world-building feeling incomplete**. Important settings were criticized for being too simplistic.
### **Neutral and Balanced Views**
* Some viewers believe that as an adaptation of a "male-oriented power fantasy" novel, the inherent "blandness" of the plot shouldn't be blamed entirely on the series, though the director failed to improve upon these weaknesses.
* Some noted the show **started strong but declined in quality** after the initial episodes.
* Overall, supporters see it as **one of the better cultivation dramas in recent years** and look forward to more, while detractors feel it wasted a major IP and beautiful locations, resulting in a mediocre or disappointing product.
The reviews for this series are **highly polarized**. **Yang Yang's visuals and the drama's special effects are its biggest attractions and strengths**, while **his acting and the director's storytelling are the primary targets of criticism**. It appears to have successfully attracted viewers who prioritize faithfulness to the source material and visual spectacle but has failed to convince those with higher demands for acting depth and narrative pacing.
* **Novel and Wildly Comedic Setting:** Praised for its transmigration + infinite flow + anti-trope + meta-commentary elements. The plot is described as "both exciting and refreshing and crazy," with addictive background music and hilarious gags (like spinning around to stab each other, or grapes not allowed to have seeds) providing an enjoyable experience. It's compared to the Korean drama *W - Two Worlds* but more exaggerated.
* **Outstanding Female Lead Performance:** Li Yitong is lauded for her stunning ancient costume look and a wide range in her acting (from lazy and laid-back to gradually growing). Some viewers believe she "deserves to be hugely popular."
* **Good for De-stressing and Casual Viewing:** The nonsensical style and dense comedic moments (like the "PPT life-saving plan" or the jabs at *Tiny Times*) make it suitable as "electronic comfort food." Some viewers reported "laughing their heads off."
* **Some Supporting Characters Shine:** The second male lead, Wang Kuan (played by Wang Youshuo), is praised as "handsome and upright," and there's anticipation for the villainous CP (couple) storyline.
### 2. Negative Reviews (Approx. 50%)
* **Chaotic Plot Logic:** Criticized for being a "hodgepodge of bad tropes" and "floating and disjointed." The transmigration loop framework wasn't utilized well (e.g., thin characterization of NPCs), and the pacing fell apart in the later stages (episodes 4-6 were a peak for viewers dropping the show).
* **Male Lead Controversy:** Liu Yuning was slammed for "greasy acting" and being "shifty-eyed," with his image not suiting ancient costumes. There were many accusations of him being a "resource magnet" (someone who gets roles due to connections rather than talent). His character's "alpha male, misogynistic" persona caused discomfort.
* **Rough Production:** Suspected of plagiarism (accused of imitating *Love Like the Galaxy* and others), the quality of an S+ tier drama was described as looking like "Bilibili fan-made content." Cheap special effects and "illegal construction" set designs were off-putting.
* **Overly Farce-like:** The entire cast's "manic" performances led to aesthetic fatigue, mocked as a "moronic drama" and "insulting to the audience's intelligence."
### 3. Neutral Reviews (Approx. 10%)
* **Strong Start, Weak Finish:** The beginning had a fresh feel, but it lacked staying power, relying on fragmented humor rather than a complete narrative.
* **Industry Reflection:** Some believe the drama is a speculative product of "long dramas becoming short dramas," reflecting a lack of creative ability in the Chinese entertainment industry.
---
### Conclusion
"A Dream with a Book" is a highly polarizing drama due to its wild and anti-trope style. Viewers who enjoyed it considered it a "de-stressing god-tier drama," while those who disliked it sharply criticized it as "crudely made." Li Yitong and the second male lead received positive reviews, while Liu Yuning's acting and the script's logic were the main points of contention. It's suitable for audiences seeking mindless fun, but those looking for plot depth or acting quality might find it difficult to accept.
**Summary of Audience Feedback on the Drama**Serendipity
**1. Controversies Over Casting and Performances**
• Negative Criticisms:
• Appearance and Suitability:
◦ Both leads (Wang Ziqi and Lu Yuxiao) face harsh criticism for their "unremarkable looks" and "lack of classical charm" in ancient costumes. Wang Ziqi is labeled a "top-tier ancient drama ugly male," while Lu Yuxiao is deemed "too ordinary for a female lead," with audiences suggesting she suits modern or supporting roles better.
◦ Lu Yuxiao’s physique and posture (e.g., slouching, "farmer-like movements") are criticized as unfit for a noblewoman character.
• Acting Skills:
◦ Wang Ziqi’s performance is called "wooden," "monotonous," and "lacking growth" since his earlier work *The Imperial Coroner*.
◦ Lu Yuxiao’s acting is deemed "stiff" and "unnatural," especially in emotional scenes. Her配音 (dubbing) is criticized as "mismatched" with her face.
• Unflattering Comparisons:
◦ The male second lead (Wang Hongyi) is praised for his "superior looks" and "youthful charm," overshadowing the male lead.
◦ Female supporting roles (e.g., Kong Xueer) are hailed as "stunning," making the female lead appear "even plainer."
• Positive Remarks:
• A minority praise Lu Yuxiao’s "lively and resilient" portrayal of the heroine and Wang Ziqi’s "natural" acting in modern dramas (though not extended to this one).
**2. Criticisms of Plot and Production Quality**
• Negative Feedback:
• Clichéd and Illogical Storytelling:
◦ The plot is dismissed as "predictable" (amnesia, revenge, pseudo-sibling tropes) and "rushed," with scenes like "rain-drenched spinning" mocked as "cringe-worthy."
◦ Pacing issues: Some call it "chaotic," while others find it "boringly slow."
• Low-Budget Aesthetics:
◦ Cheap props (e.g., "foam cabinets"), poor lighting (harsh snowfield lighting), and "washed-out filters" are ridiculed.
◦ Costumes and wigs are labeled "tacky" and "unconvincing."
• Modernized Dialogue and Themes:
◦ Phrases like "girls help girls" feel anachronistic in a historical setting.
◦ The female lead’s "entrepreneurial" arc is seen as a lazy trend-following trope.
• Positive Notes:
• Some appreciate the "female solidarity" moments (e.g., the heroine exposing a cheating fiancé) and find the plot "fast-paced" in early episodes.
**3. Broader Industry Criticisms**
• Casting and Nepotism:
• Audiences slam the industry for "forcing mediocre actors into lead roles" and question the "declining standards" of ancient dramas.
• Lu Yuxiao’s reliance on Guo Jingming’s stylized direction (e.g., *Story of Shadows*) is noted, with critics claiming she "can’t shine without his team."
• Polarized Reception:
• Harsh reviews dominate, calling the drama "an insult to viewers" and "low-quality industrial trash."
• A few viewers defend it as "mindless fun" or praise secondary characters’ chemistry.
## **1. Major Criticisms**
- **Clichéd Plot**: The "revenge after rebirth" trope lacks originality, with fast-paced but illogical storytelling (e.g., simplistic schemes like breaking off an engagement).
- **Poor Production**: Artificial lighting, low-quality cinematography, and chaotic editing with excessive flashbacks.
- **Acting Controversies**:
- **Zhang Wanyi**: Repeatedly criticized for "wooden acting" and "unchanging expressions," with his historical drama roles blending into one another (*The Long Ballad*, *Love on the Sword*, etc.).
- **Jing Tian**: Called out for "aging poorly" and "stiff facial expressions," lacking emotional depth in romantic scenes.
- **Lack of Chemistry**: The leads' interactions were mocked as resembling "aunt and nephew" rather than lovers.
#### **2. Few Praises**
- **Fast-Paced Revenge**: Some viewers enjoyed the rapid start (rebirth within minutes) and cathartic moments (e.g., the heroine slapping villains).
- **Female Characters**: A minority praised certain antagonists (e.g., the power-hungry princess) and the heroine’s independence.
- **Supporting Cast**: Ma Su’s performance and Zhang Chi’s comedic relief received minor acclaim.
#### **3. Audience Suggestions**
- **For the Leads**: Zhang Wanyi was urged to "return to period dramas," while Jing Tian was advised to "switch to modern roles."
- **For the Production Team**: The writers were blasted for "prioritizing cheap thrills over logic," and the director was told to improve narrative coherence.
#### **4. Final Verdict**
- **For Whom?**: Only suitable for viewers seeking mindless escapism.
- **Avoid If**: You value plot logic, acting skill, or production quality.
Chinese Audience's Opinions on This Movie Creation of The Gods Ⅱ: Demon Forces Demon
### **Movie Review Summary**
The film received polarized reviews. Many viewers criticized the protagonist, Ji Fa, for being indecisive and lacking the charisma of a true leader, which made the storyline feel dragged out and lacking intensity. Instead, the female general, Deng Chanyu, emerged as the film’s biggest highlight, displaying bravery and decisiveness. Some even believed she was more suited to be the "Ruler of All."
The romantic subplot was controversial. Some audiences were dissatisfied with how Deng Chanyu, initially portrayed as a strong and heroic warrior, was later reduced to a love-struck character, which weakened her appeal. Additionally, supporting characters like the Four Demon Generals and Yang Jian were seen as lacking depth and serving merely as plot devices.
The film’s visual effects received mixed reactions. While the three-headed, six-armed Yin Jiao’s CGI was criticized as rough, the overall battle sequences were also deemed underwhelming, failing to deliver an epic scale. Some viewers felt the film fell short compared to its predecessor, with a lackluster script and war scenes that did not meet expectations.
Overall, the film faced significant criticism for its character development, plot progression, and CGI quality. However, Deng Chanyu's portrayal stood out as one of the few widely praised aspects.
The opinions of Chinese audiences on Moonlight Mystique
Positive Reviews:
Appearance and Chemistry: Many viewers believe that the lead actors are visually appealing and have good chemistry, especially Bai Lu and Ao Ruipeng, who have received considerable praise.
Pacing: Some viewers find the plot fast-paced and rich in information, with no unnecessary dragging, particularly in the early episodes, which are tightly packed and engaging.
Character Design: The character of Bai Shuo, the female lead, has received much praise for being smart and not a typical "dumb sweet" character, with a distinct personality that leaves a strong impression.
Costumes, Makeup, and Special Effects: The show's costumes, makeup, and special effects have also garnered positive feedback, especially the visual effects and scene designs, which are considered exquisite.
Acting Performance: Bai Lu's acting and dialogue delivery have been recognized by some viewers, particularly her lively performance and emotional expression.
Negative Reviews:
Clichéd Plot: Many viewers feel that the plot lacks originality, with many scenes resembling those in other fantasy dramas, leading to a high "similarity rate" and a lack of creativity.
Dialogue and Dubbing: Some viewers are dissatisfied with Bai Lu's original voice acting, finding her voice grating and her emotional delivery lacking, suggesting the use of a dubbing actor instead.
Character Design and Acting: Some viewers find Ao Ruipeng's acting stiff and his character overly pretentious, lacking appeal. Additionally, some feel that Bai Lu appears older, which weakens the chemistry with the male lead.
Overuse of Filters and Beauty Effects: The excessive use of filters and beauty effects in the show makes the characters' faces appear unnatural, detracting from the viewing experience.
Plot Logic and Dragging: Some viewers find the plot logic lacking, especially in the middle and later episodes, where the pacing drags and fails to maintain interest.
Summary:
Overall, audience opinions on this drama are polarized. Those who enjoy it appreciate its fast-paced plot, interesting character designs, and impressive visuals. However, those who are critical find the plot clichéd, the dialogue and acting subpar, and the over-reliance on filters and beauty effects off-putting. If you are a fan of fantasy dramas, you might find this show appealing, but if you have high expectations for plot innovation and acting performance, you might find it somewhat mediocre.
1. Production and Visual Effects Many viewers praised the drama for its high production quality and stunning visuals. The director excelled in capturing both characters and landscapes, along with the cinematography, costumes, and props. Specific mentions were made of the atmospheric tone, the aesthetics of traditional Chinese elements, and the beautifully designed snow scenes and transitions, showcasing meticulous attention to detail.
2. Plot and Pacing The storyline is fast-paced, with a gripping opening and a mix of rebirth, family intrigue, and political scheming, which garnered positive feedback. Some noted that the adaptation from the original novel streamlined unnecessary subplots, making it more cohesive. However, a few viewers felt the plot was still somewhat thin, particularly regarding the political intrigue. While there are criticisms about the plot being formulaic like typical web novels, the themes of fate and well-handled symbolism remain compelling for many.
3. Character Performances Meng Ziyi: Opinions about her were polarized. Some praised her beauty and fit for the role, while others criticized her acting and reliance on dubbing. Li Yunrui: His appearance and styling sparked debate. While his white-haired look received approval, some felt his acting lacked natural expression. Supporting Cast: Actors like Ye Zuxin were commended for their strong performances and alignment with their characters. In contrast, Xia Zhiguang’s appearance and acting style left some viewers dissatisfied.
4. Strengths and Weaknesses Strengths: High-quality production and immersive atmosphere. Smart and competent characters, breaking away from the usual clichés of historical romance dramas. Technical aspects like music, lighting, and cinematography were well-executed. Weaknesses: Criticism of certain performances and dubbing. Overuse of slow-motion and pacing issues, giving the impression of a music video or short-form drama. Some logical gaps and inconsistencies in the storyline.
5. Overall Evaluation Despite some shortcomings, the drama’s impressive visuals, solid adaptation, and competent portrayal of certain characters left a positive impression on audiences. Many are optimistic about how the plot and performances will develop in later episodes. Overall, it stands out as a relatively outstanding historical romance drama, especially in a market filled with subpar productions.
Chinese star news
Based on the provided Douban comments, here is a summary of the audience feedback for this TV series (adapted from *Rebirth of a Female General Star* and titled *Legend of The Female General*):
---
### **Main Criticisms (Concentrated Negative Feedback)**
1. **Heavy Plot Alterations, Deviating from the Original Core**
- Removal of the crucial "rebirth" element weakens the female lead's motivation for revenge (betrayal by family, murder by former husband), diminishing the story's tension and logic.
- Key plot points (e.g., the brother impersonating the protagonist) lack credibility. The fact that the entire court fails to distinguish between siblings with completely different builds and voices is criticized as "insulting to intelligence."
- Many iconic scenes from the original are cut, while newly added plots (e.g., embracing on the battlefield, coincidental hot spring encounters) are labeled as "industrial sugar" and "forced romance."
2. **Character Derailment, Female General Becomes "Trophy Wife"**
- The female lead, meant to be a resilient and decisive general, frequently displays "acting cute," "coquettishness," and "girlish mannerisms," criticized as "fake strong female lead, real trophy wife."
- The actress's petite and slender physique (mocked as "chick-sized") lacks the imposing presence expected of a "general." While there are many action scenes, they lack conviction.
- The male lead is altered to be more dominant, and the plot overemphasizes the romantic line, resulting in a "strong female lead, even stronger male lead" dynamic that undermines the female lead's independence.
3. **Acting and Dubbing Issues**
- Zhou Ye's acting is criticized as "wooden" and lacking in expressive eyes, especially in blind scenes where her performance shows no difference after regaining sight. However, some viewers praise her androgynous look in male attire.
- Cheng Lei's performance is considered flat, with dubbing that doesn't match his face. His character is perceived as an "expressionless ice block" with little depth.
- The overall dubbing is criticized as "lifeless" and "not fitting the characters."
4. **Logical Flaws and Sloppy Details**
- The plot is jumpy with abrupt transitions (e.g., blindness cured in 5 minutes, sudden embraces and kisses on the battlefield).
- Military aspects are trivialized (impractical masks, lax camp management), and the political intrigue subplot is weak.
- Dialogue is preachy and slogan-like (e.g., "women can also achieve great deeds"), coming across as forced.
5. **Casting Controversies**
- Zhou Ye is considered too "delicate" in appearance to portray a female general; the male lead is also described as having "rat-like features" and being "too effeminate."
- Supporting role casting (e.g., Yan He transformed into a middle-aged man) causes dissatisfaction, and some important characters are cut.
---
### **Points of Praise and Support (Minority Positive Feedback)**
1. **Actors' Visual Appeal and Styling**
- Zhou Ye's male attire is praised as "handsome" and "heroic," while her female looks are also called "stunning."
- Some viewers appreciate the high attractiveness of the leads and the visually pleasing scenes.
2. **Action Choreography and Production**
- The fight sequences are well-designed and fluid (action direction by the team from *Strange Tales of Tang Dynasty*), with some action scenes receiving recognition.
- Costumes, makeup, sets, and overall visual quality receive some positive remarks.
3. **Perceived Rationality of Adaptations**
- A minority of viewers believe removing the rebirth and inner-house conflict plots makes the story tighter, and focusing on "revenge in the present life" is more logical.
- Some appreciate plot points like the male lead quickly discovering the female lead's identity and the faster progression of the romance.
---
### **Divergence in Audience Groups**
- **Original Novel Fans Largely Disappointed**: They feel the adaptation loses the essence of the original, with severe alterations, mostly giving 1-2 star ratings.
- **TV-Only Viewers Are Divided**: Some find it "watchable as light entertainment," while others criticize the clichéd plot and logical flaws.
- **Actors' Fans Are Supportive**: They primarily praise the leads' looks and styling, being more tolerant of plot controversies.
---
### **Overall Summary**
The series is highly controversial. The core issue is that **"the alterations severely weaken the original's strong female lead core,"** leading to character derailment and logical flaws. While the production and action choreography have some merits, and the leads' visuals are praised, the plot adaptation, acting performances, and attention to detail face substantial criticism. Based on these Douban comments, **negative feedback dominates**, especially from original novel fans and viewers who prioritize plot logic. Overall, the reception reflects "high expectations, low satisfaction," with the series criticized as "yet another pseudo-strong-female-lead historical romance."
2 months ago | [YT] | 10
View 1 reply
Chinese star news
What do Chinese viewers think of the TV series The Immortal Ascension?
This TV drama adaptation of "A Record of a Mortal's Journey to Immortality," starring Yang Yang, has sparked widespread and polarized discussions, with focus primarily on the following aspects:
### **Praise and Highlights**
1. **Yang Yang's Appearance and Perceived Improvement:**
* **Positive Views:** Many viewers consider Yang Yang's **ancient costume appearance to be outstanding**, perfectly matching the handsome image of the protagonist, Han Li. Some comments noted that compared to his previous works, his performance in this drama showed some **improvement, being less "oily" and more natural**.
* **Praise for Production:** Many reviews praised the magnificent visuals from **on-location shooting** and the **film-level special effects**, considering the fight scenes exciting and the VFX plentiful and sincere, far exceeding the standard for typical domestic dramas.
* **Plot Fidelity and Pacing:** Some original novel and anime fans were satisfied with the **faithfulness to the source material**, finding the beginning well-paced and the main storyline clear, calling it an immersive "immortality cultivation" story. The female director's **skill in depicting nuanced emotions** (e.g., the portrayal of characters like Doctor Mo) was also praised.
### **Criticism and Controversy**
1. **Strong Criticism of Yang Yang's Acting:**
* This is the most contentious point. A significant number of viewers feel his performance remains **"oily," "affected," and "stiff,"** with a "news anchor-like" tone and unclear diction. They argue he failed to capture Han Li's essential traits of **caution, restraint, and intelligence**, instead coming across as "slow-witted" or "overconfident."
* Many critics compared his performance to his past roles, believing he has shown little improvement.
2. **Issues with Direction, Script, and Pacing:**
* Many comments point to **weak narrative skills from the director**, stating the plot feels like a "tedious流水账 (lit. running water account)" or a "scenic MV," with **poor pacing** (slow when it should be fast, and vice versa) and a lack of dramatic tension.
* **Inappropriate use of BGM** was cited, being described as overly abundant, chaotic, and mismatched with the scene's atmosphere.
* **Excessive use of voice-over narration** was criticized as a lazy way to explain characters' inner thoughts.
3. **Casting and Supporting Roles:**
* Beyond Yang Yang, **several actresses (e.g., Jin Chen, Liu Yan, Ying Er)** were criticized for being **miscast or incongruous** with their roles.
* The acting of some **supporting characters** was deemed exaggerated and one-dimensional.
4. **Flaws in Production Details:**
* While the VFX were praised overall, some early effects were called cheap and unimpressive.
* **Costumes, makeup, props, and set design** were considered rough by some, with the **world-building feeling incomplete**. Important settings were criticized for being too simplistic.
### **Neutral and Balanced Views**
* Some viewers believe that as an adaptation of a "male-oriented power fantasy" novel, the inherent "blandness" of the plot shouldn't be blamed entirely on the series, though the director failed to improve upon these weaknesses.
* Some noted the show **started strong but declined in quality** after the initial episodes.
* Overall, supporters see it as **one of the better cultivation dramas in recent years** and look forward to more, while detractors feel it wasted a major IP and beautiful locations, resulting in a mediocre or disappointing product.
The reviews for this series are **highly polarized**. **Yang Yang's visuals and the drama's special effects are its biggest attractions and strengths**, while **his acting and the director's storytelling are the primary targets of criticism**. It appears to have successfully attracted viewers who prioritize faithfulness to the source material and visual spectacle but has failed to convince those with higher demands for acting depth and narrative pacing.
4 months ago | [YT] | 33
View 2 replies
Chinese star news
"A Dream Within A Dream" Drama Review Summary
### 1. Positive Reviews (Approx. 40%)
* **Novel and Wildly Comedic Setting:** Praised for its transmigration + infinite flow + anti-trope + meta-commentary elements. The plot is described as "both exciting and refreshing and crazy," with addictive background music and hilarious gags (like spinning around to stab each other, or grapes not allowed to have seeds) providing an enjoyable experience. It's compared to the Korean drama *W - Two Worlds* but more exaggerated.
* **Outstanding Female Lead Performance:** Li Yitong is lauded for her stunning ancient costume look and a wide range in her acting (from lazy and laid-back to gradually growing). Some viewers believe she "deserves to be hugely popular."
* **Good for De-stressing and Casual Viewing:** The nonsensical style and dense comedic moments (like the "PPT life-saving plan" or the jabs at *Tiny Times*) make it suitable as "electronic comfort food." Some viewers reported "laughing their heads off."
* **Some Supporting Characters Shine:** The second male lead, Wang Kuan (played by Wang Youshuo), is praised as "handsome and upright," and there's anticipation for the villainous CP (couple) storyline.
### 2. Negative Reviews (Approx. 50%)
* **Chaotic Plot Logic:** Criticized for being a "hodgepodge of bad tropes" and "floating and disjointed." The transmigration loop framework wasn't utilized well (e.g., thin characterization of NPCs), and the pacing fell apart in the later stages (episodes 4-6 were a peak for viewers dropping the show).
* **Male Lead Controversy:** Liu Yuning was slammed for "greasy acting" and being "shifty-eyed," with his image not suiting ancient costumes. There were many accusations of him being a "resource magnet" (someone who gets roles due to connections rather than talent). His character's "alpha male, misogynistic" persona caused discomfort.
* **Rough Production:** Suspected of plagiarism (accused of imitating *Love Like the Galaxy* and others), the quality of an S+ tier drama was described as looking like "Bilibili fan-made content." Cheap special effects and "illegal construction" set designs were off-putting.
* **Overly Farce-like:** The entire cast's "manic" performances led to aesthetic fatigue, mocked as a "moronic drama" and "insulting to the audience's intelligence."
### 3. Neutral Reviews (Approx. 10%)
* **Strong Start, Weak Finish:** The beginning had a fresh feel, but it lacked staying power, relying on fragmented humor rather than a complete narrative.
* **Industry Reflection:** Some believe the drama is a speculative product of "long dramas becoming short dramas," reflecting a lack of creative ability in the Chinese entertainment industry.
---
### Conclusion
"A Dream with a Book" is a highly polarizing drama due to its wild and anti-trope style. Viewers who enjoyed it considered it a "de-stressing god-tier drama," while those who disliked it sharply criticized it as "crudely made." Li Yitong and the second male lead received positive reviews, while Liu Yuning's acting and the script's logic were the main points of contention. It's suitable for audiences seeking mindless fun, but those looking for plot depth or acting quality might find it difficult to accept.
7 months ago | [YT] | 47
View 3 replies
Chinese star news
**Summary of Audience Feedback on the Drama**Serendipity
**1. Controversies Over Casting and Performances**
• Negative Criticisms:
• Appearance and Suitability:
◦ Both leads (Wang Ziqi and Lu Yuxiao) face harsh criticism for their "unremarkable looks" and "lack of classical charm" in ancient costumes. Wang Ziqi is labeled a "top-tier ancient drama ugly male," while Lu Yuxiao is deemed "too ordinary for a female lead," with audiences suggesting she suits modern or supporting roles better.
◦ Lu Yuxiao’s physique and posture (e.g., slouching, "farmer-like movements") are criticized as unfit for a noblewoman character.
• Acting Skills:
◦ Wang Ziqi’s performance is called "wooden," "monotonous," and "lacking growth" since his earlier work *The Imperial Coroner*.
◦ Lu Yuxiao’s acting is deemed "stiff" and "unnatural," especially in emotional scenes. Her配音 (dubbing) is criticized as "mismatched" with her face.
• Unflattering Comparisons:
◦ The male second lead (Wang Hongyi) is praised for his "superior looks" and "youthful charm," overshadowing the male lead.
◦ Female supporting roles (e.g., Kong Xueer) are hailed as "stunning," making the female lead appear "even plainer."
• Positive Remarks:
• A minority praise Lu Yuxiao’s "lively and resilient" portrayal of the heroine and Wang Ziqi’s "natural" acting in modern dramas (though not extended to this one).
**2. Criticisms of Plot and Production Quality**
• Negative Feedback:
• Clichéd and Illogical Storytelling:
◦ The plot is dismissed as "predictable" (amnesia, revenge, pseudo-sibling tropes) and "rushed," with scenes like "rain-drenched spinning" mocked as "cringe-worthy."
◦ Pacing issues: Some call it "chaotic," while others find it "boringly slow."
• Low-Budget Aesthetics:
◦ Cheap props (e.g., "foam cabinets"), poor lighting (harsh snowfield lighting), and "washed-out filters" are ridiculed.
◦ Costumes and wigs are labeled "tacky" and "unconvincing."
• Modernized Dialogue and Themes:
◦ Phrases like "girls help girls" feel anachronistic in a historical setting.
◦ The female lead’s "entrepreneurial" arc is seen as a lazy trend-following trope.
• Positive Notes:
• Some appreciate the "female solidarity" moments (e.g., the heroine exposing a cheating fiancé) and find the plot "fast-paced" in early episodes.
**3. Broader Industry Criticisms**
• Casting and Nepotism:
• Audiences slam the industry for "forcing mediocre actors into lead roles" and question the "declining standards" of ancient dramas.
• Lu Yuxiao’s reliance on Guo Jingming’s stylized direction (e.g., *Story of Shadows*) is noted, with critics claiming she "can’t shine without his team."
• Polarized Reception:
• Harsh reviews dominate, calling the drama "an insult to viewers" and "low-quality industrial trash."
• A few viewers defend it as "mindless fun" or praise secondary characters’ chemistry.
8 months ago | [YT] | 34
View 3 replies
Chinese star news
Chinese audiences' reviews of the TV drama SI Jin
## **1. Major Criticisms**
- **Clichéd Plot**: The "revenge after rebirth" trope lacks originality, with fast-paced but illogical storytelling (e.g., simplistic schemes like breaking off an engagement).
- **Poor Production**: Artificial lighting, low-quality cinematography, and chaotic editing with excessive flashbacks.
- **Acting Controversies**:
- **Zhang Wanyi**: Repeatedly criticized for "wooden acting" and "unchanging expressions," with his historical drama roles blending into one another (*The Long Ballad*, *Love on the Sword*, etc.).
- **Jing Tian**: Called out for "aging poorly" and "stiff facial expressions," lacking emotional depth in romantic scenes.
- **Lack of Chemistry**: The leads' interactions were mocked as resembling "aunt and nephew" rather than lovers.
#### **2. Few Praises**
- **Fast-Paced Revenge**: Some viewers enjoyed the rapid start (rebirth within minutes) and cathartic moments (e.g., the heroine slapping villains).
- **Female Characters**: A minority praised certain antagonists (e.g., the power-hungry princess) and the heroine’s independence.
- **Supporting Cast**: Ma Su’s performance and Zhang Chi’s comedic relief received minor acclaim.
#### **3. Audience Suggestions**
- **For the Leads**: Zhang Wanyi was urged to "return to period dramas," while Jing Tian was advised to "switch to modern roles."
- **For the Production Team**: The writers were blasted for "prioritizing cheap thrills over logic," and the director was told to improve narrative coherence.
#### **4. Final Verdict**
- **For Whom?**: Only suitable for viewers seeking mindless escapism.
- **Avoid If**: You value plot logic, acting skill, or production quality.
10 months ago | [YT] | 28
View 0 replies
Chinese star news
Chinese Audience's Opinions on This Movie Creation of The Gods Ⅱ: Demon Forces Demon
### **Movie Review Summary**
The film received polarized reviews. Many viewers criticized the protagonist, Ji Fa, for being indecisive and lacking the charisma of a true leader, which made the storyline feel dragged out and lacking intensity. Instead, the female general, Deng Chanyu, emerged as the film’s biggest highlight, displaying bravery and decisiveness. Some even believed she was more suited to be the "Ruler of All."
The romantic subplot was controversial. Some audiences were dissatisfied with how Deng Chanyu, initially portrayed as a strong and heroic warrior, was later reduced to a love-struck character, which weakened her appeal. Additionally, supporting characters like the Four Demon Generals and Yang Jian were seen as lacking depth and serving merely as plot devices.
The film’s visual effects received mixed reactions. While the three-headed, six-armed Yin Jiao’s CGI was criticized as rough, the overall battle sequences were also deemed underwhelming, failing to deliver an epic scale. Some viewers felt the film fell short compared to its predecessor, with a lackluster script and war scenes that did not meet expectations.
Overall, the film faced significant criticism for its character development, plot progression, and CGI quality. However, Deng Chanyu's portrayal stood out as one of the few widely praised aspects.
1 year ago | [YT] | 9
View 0 replies
Chinese star news
The opinions of Chinese audiences on Moonlight Mystique
Positive Reviews:
Appearance and Chemistry: Many viewers believe that the lead actors are visually appealing and have good chemistry, especially Bai Lu and Ao Ruipeng, who have received considerable praise.
Pacing: Some viewers find the plot fast-paced and rich in information, with no unnecessary dragging, particularly in the early episodes, which are tightly packed and engaging.
Character Design: The character of Bai Shuo, the female lead, has received much praise for being smart and not a typical "dumb sweet" character, with a distinct personality that leaves a strong impression.
Costumes, Makeup, and Special Effects: The show's costumes, makeup, and special effects have also garnered positive feedback, especially the visual effects and scene designs, which are considered exquisite.
Acting Performance: Bai Lu's acting and dialogue delivery have been recognized by some viewers, particularly her lively performance and emotional expression.
Negative Reviews:
Clichéd Plot: Many viewers feel that the plot lacks originality, with many scenes resembling those in other fantasy dramas, leading to a high "similarity rate" and a lack of creativity.
Dialogue and Dubbing: Some viewers are dissatisfied with Bai Lu's original voice acting, finding her voice grating and her emotional delivery lacking, suggesting the use of a dubbing actor instead.
Character Design and Acting: Some viewers find Ao Ruipeng's acting stiff and his character overly pretentious, lacking appeal. Additionally, some feel that Bai Lu appears older, which weakens the chemistry with the male lead.
Overuse of Filters and Beauty Effects: The excessive use of filters and beauty effects in the show makes the characters' faces appear unnatural, detracting from the viewing experience.
Plot Logic and Dragging: Some viewers find the plot logic lacking, especially in the middle and later episodes, where the pacing drags and fails to maintain interest.
Summary:
Overall, audience opinions on this drama are polarized. Those who enjoy it appreciate its fast-paced plot, interesting character designs, and impressive visuals. However, those who are critical find the plot clichéd, the dialogue and acting subpar, and the over-reliance on filters and beauty effects off-putting. If you are a fan of fantasy dramas, you might find this show appealing, but if you have high expectations for plot innovation and acting performance, you might find it somewhat mediocre.
1 year ago | [YT] | 124
View 5 replies
Chinese star news
Drama：Blossom
1. Production and Visual Effects
Many viewers praised the drama for its high production quality and stunning visuals. The director excelled in capturing both characters and landscapes, along with the cinematography, costumes, and props.
Specific mentions were made of the atmospheric tone, the aesthetics of traditional Chinese elements, and the beautifully designed snow scenes and transitions, showcasing meticulous attention to detail.
2. Plot and Pacing
The storyline is fast-paced, with a gripping opening and a mix of rebirth, family intrigue, and political scheming, which garnered positive feedback.
Some noted that the adaptation from the original novel streamlined unnecessary subplots, making it more cohesive. However, a few viewers felt the plot was still somewhat thin, particularly regarding the political intrigue.
While there are criticisms about the plot being formulaic like typical web novels, the themes of fate and well-handled symbolism remain compelling for many.
3. Character Performances
Meng Ziyi: Opinions about her were polarized. Some praised her beauty and fit for the role, while others criticized her acting and reliance on dubbing.
Li Yunrui: His appearance and styling sparked debate. While his white-haired look received approval, some felt his acting lacked natural expression.
Supporting Cast: Actors like Ye Zuxin were commended for their strong performances and alignment with their characters. In contrast, Xia Zhiguang’s appearance and acting style left some viewers dissatisfied.
4. Strengths and Weaknesses
Strengths:
High-quality production and immersive atmosphere.
Smart and competent characters, breaking away from the usual clichés of historical romance dramas.
Technical aspects like music, lighting, and cinematography were well-executed.
Weaknesses:
Criticism of certain performances and dubbing.
Overuse of slow-motion and pacing issues, giving the impression of a music video or short-form drama.
Some logical gaps and inconsistencies in the storyline.
5. Overall Evaluation
Despite some shortcomings, the drama’s impressive visuals, solid adaptation, and competent portrayal of certain characters left a positive impression on audiences.
Many are optimistic about how the plot and performances will develop in later episodes.
Overall, it stands out as a relatively outstanding historical romance drama, especially in a market filled with subpar productions.
1 year ago | [YT] | 65
View 1 reply
Chinese star news
Zhao Lusi’s TV drama has received a score of 6.0. How do Chinese netizens evaluate this TV series? Let’s take a look at some of the popular reviews.
1 year ago | [YT] | 32
View 3 replies
Chinese star news
The joke that Luo Yunxi told made Bai Lu even more speechless
2 years ago | [YT] | 23
View 0 replies
Load more